Thinking about selling your home FSBO — For Sale by Owner — to save on commission? You’re not alone. Many North Atlanta homeowners believe that if they skip hiring a realtor, they’ll keep more money at closing.
It’s an appealing idea. After all, a 5–6% commission sounds like a lot. But here’s the truth: while FSBO can look like a smart financial decision on paper, it often costs sellers far more in the end.
In this post, I’ll break down why FSBO homes usually sell for less, the risks you may not see coming, and how working with an experienced agent can actually increase your net profit.
Why Sellers Choose FSBO
The number one reason homeowners go FSBO is simple: saving commission.
You might think:
- “I can take my own photos, put the house online, and handle showings myself.”
- “I know my home better than anyone — why should I pay someone else to sell it?”
- “The market is hot — homes are selling fast. Why not try it on my own first?”
These are valid questions. But the reality is, commission isn’t the only number that matters. The real number you should focus on is your
net at closing.
The Hidden Costs of FSBO
Here’s where FSBO starts to break down.
1. Lower Sale Price
According to the National Association of Realtors (NAR), FSBO homes sell for 8–16% less than agent-listed homes. That means if your home is worth $600,000, you could realistically end up selling for just $504,000–$552,000.
2. Longer Time on Market
FSBO homes usually sit longer, especially without professional marketing. Meanwhile, in North Atlanta right now, properly priced agent-listed homes are selling in 14–21 days at or near list price.
3. Safety Concerns
Selling on your own means you’re the one opening your door to strangers. Without pre-qualification or screening, you have no way of knowing who’s walking through your home.
4. Legal & Contract Risks
Real estate contracts are full of details that protect buyers and sellers. Miss a disclosure or agree to the wrong terms, and you could lose thousands. For example, most buyers can terminate a contract in at least three ways — inspection, appraisal, or financing. Sellers? You typically have no termination rights. That imbalance catches many FSBO sellers by surprise.
A Real-Life Example
Recently, I worked with a family who relocated to North Atlanta from Florida. They decided to sell their Florida home on their own. To complicate things, their parents were licensed realtors — but not active in the business.
They accepted an offer that looked good on paper. But soon, problems piled up:
- The buyer’s financing wasn’t strong.
- The due diligence period was unusually long.
- The appraisal came in low.
- And because of the way the contract was written, the sellers couldn’t even keep the earnest money when the buyer backed out.
What started as a plan to “save money” turned into months of stress, uncertainty, and financial loss.
The Exposure Problem
Here’s one of the biggest issues with FSBO: exposure.
Most FSBO homes end up only on Zillow, Craigslist, or a yard sign. But that’s not where serious buyers are looking. Almost all buyers work with agents, and those agents use MLS searches to find homes.
If your home isn’t in MLS, it doesn’t show up in the searches buyers are relying on. When I list a property, it gets syndicated to thousands of websites — Realtor.com, http://Homes.com , brokerage sites, Redfin, buyer apps, even international portals.
FSBO = limited exposure.
Agent-listed = maximum exposure.
And more exposure means more buyers, more competition, and higher offers.
The $600,000 Example (North Atlanta)
Let’s put this into numbers:
- FSBO: List at $600,000 → Sell for $504,000–$552,000 (8–16% less). That’s before repairs and closing costs.
- Agent-Listed: List at $600,000 → Sell for $564,000–$567,000 in 14–21 days. Even after commission, sellers typically walk away with a higher net.
And here’s another advantage: an experienced agent knows what buyers expect for closing costs, and which repairs are truly necessary. That guidance alone can save thousands.
FSBO vs. Agent Marketing
FSBO Tools: Yard sign, iPhone photos, Zillow listing.
Agent Tools: Professional photography, staging, MLS exposure, digital ads, open houses, database marketing, and strong negotiation skills.
The difference? FSBO homes get seen by fewer buyers, while agent-listed homes get competitive offers.
Commission Reframed
It’s easy to look at commission as money “lost.” But here’s the reality:
The better question isn’t:
“What’s the commission?”
The better question is:
“What will I actually net at the closing table?”
Most sellers are shocked to find that even after commission, they still net more with an agent.
If you’re thinking about selling FSBO in North Atlanta, make sure you understand the full picture. Yes, you might save on commission. But you could lose far more in price, time, safety, and peace of mind.
📍 Want to know your real numbers?
I’ll create a
personalized Seller Net Sheet for your home — no obligation, just clarity.
📲 Call/Text:
404.434.4454
📩 Email:
irina.a@kw.com
🌐
http://keystonorthatlanta.com
Even if you decide to sell on your own, you’ll walk away with the confidence of knowing exactly where you stand.
